I also bought a nail kit for $1.50. I'm probably going to throw the polish out but I picked it up for the heart sequins and nail stickes that I can use with my daughter.
I picked up an E.L.F. Eye gift set for $1.50. It comes with an eyeliner, eyeshadow, eyelash curler, mascara and brush. I love their brushes so it was worth it just for the brush.
I also picked up 3 of my favorite nail polish remover pads. Each one has 25 pads perfect for getting all kinds of polish off. You can find them for clearance for .49 cents.